When I bought SUPERMAN From The '30s To The '70s in late 1972, I instantly recognised three stories from the 80 page giant: The CASE Of The FUNNY PAPER CRIMES, The MYSTERIOUS Mr. MXYZPTLK, and SUPERMAN, CARTOON HERO. However, when I obtained a replacement copy of this issue a couple or so years ago, there was one adventure I didn't recall at all - WHEN SUPERMAN LOST HIS POWERS. Some aspects from another tale, The EYE Of METROPOLIS, seemed vaguely familiar - but had I not seen it again first, I doubt the suggestion of memory would ever have occurred unprompted.
So why did I seemingly forget those two tales as opposed to the other three? Was it because their splash pages weren't featured on the cover and therefore made less of an impression on me? Or could it be that, not having appeared in the '72 Superman book, their previous association wasn't reinforced in my memory like the other strips were? Perhaps it's simply the case that the stories weren't particularly memorable. Guess I'll never really know for sure, but it's unlike me to forget two stories in one comic.
Oh, absolutely Kid, absolutely. My recollection of this comic is very specific as well.
ReplyDeleteI bought it brand new off the racks at the Woolworth's at the JCRS shopping center near my house. The weather was blue skies and a few scattered clouds. My mother was shopping at the fabric store, and I curled up somewhere with this comic and was transported. I had only read a few golden age stories at that time, mostly from Jules Feiffer's superhero book, and I was stunned to see an Elmer Fuddish Mr. Mxyzptlk, almost sweet and innocent. The story where the animated Superman feature was playing with Superman and Lois in the audience blew my mind. I went back and bought a second issue so that I could cut it up for my scrapbook of kool komic stuff.
I read and reread that comic a hundred times, and I still have the same intact copy I bought on that blue sky day.
Geez, you and I use the same time machine.
Thom, I'm impressed - the same copy from all those years ago? In fact, I'm jealous. Maybe we're the same person from different points in time, currently inhabiting the same time continuum - you know, like Doctor Doom and Pharaoh Rama-Tut?
ReplyDeleteTime for my reality pill.
I traded off a lot of comics over the years, but I always kept key issues that triggered memories, such as this one.
ReplyDeleteI kept the first comic I ever bought off the spinner back in the '50s (Uncle Scrooge), my first 3 DC superhero comics circa 1961, and other sentimental stuff like that there.
My comment moderation words are tmenhisi essums, which I'm thinking is Latin for "throw your reality pills down the drain, life is stranger than we imagine.
Or, to put it another way - "There are more things in heaven and earth, Horatio, than are dreamt of in your philosophy."
ReplyDeleteAll too true, Thom - all too true.